• Style
  • Women
  • Huff/Post50
  • Weddings
  • HealthyLiving
  • Divorce
  • Parents
  • Sign In / Register
  • stylelist home
  • huffpost style
  • FASHION
    • Departments

      Fashion News Fashion Features Fashion Trends Designers Models Accessories
      In The Market For Intern Diaries Step Into My Office Object of My Affection Stylelist Network Stories

      Featured

      Can You Guess The Child Model's Famous Aunt? Can You Guess The Child Model's Famous Aunt?
      Vintage-Obsessed Blogger Shares 18 Recent Finds Vintage-Obsessed Blogger Shares 18 Recent Finds
      Pinterest Cracks Down On Thinspirational Images Pinterest Cracks Down On Thinspirational Images
  • BEAUTY
    • Departments

      Beauty Basics Beauty News Beauty Features Beauty Trends Uptown Downtown Makeup Healthy Beautiful You
      Skin & Body Fragrance Nails Facetime The Unexpected Icon

      Featured

      The SPF Level You Should <i>Actually</i> Be Wearing The SPF Level You Should Actually Be Wearing
      Do You Use A Facespray Like This Yoga Instructor? Do You Use A Facespray Like This Yoga Instructor?
      Morgan Spurlock Waxes Philosophical On Mantyhose & Manscaping Morgan Spurlock Waxes Philosophical On Mantyhose & Manscaping
  • HAIR
    • Departments

      Hair Trends Hair How To

      Featured

      The Hair Doctor Is in: Consultation Is Key The Hair Doctor Is in: Consultation Is Key
      Guess Which Beauty Treatment She Gave The President Guess Which Beauty Treatment She Gave The President
      Can Pink Hair Look Sophisticated? Can Pink Hair Look Sophisticated?
  • CELEBRITY
    • Departments

      Style Evolution Look Of The Day Uptown|Downtown A Look Back

      Featured

      How Donna Summer Helped Me Through College How Donna Summer Helped Me Through College
      PHOTOS: Cameron Diaz's Life In 54 Looks PHOTOS: Cameron Diaz's Life In 54 Looks
      PHOTOS: 27 Stars Who Look More Beautiful Without Makeup PHOTOS: 27 Stars Who Look More Beautiful Without Makeup
  • CULTURE
    • Departments

      Art & Design Film Music Books & Magazines

      Featured

      How Long Does It Take To Become Mrs. Don Draper? How Long Does It Take To Become Mrs. Don Draper?
      5 Things This Hot New Musician Can't Live Without 5 Things This Hot New Musician Can't Live Without
      PHOTOS: SXSW Street Style PHOTOS: SXSW Street Style
  • FASHION WEEK
    • Departments

      Fashion Week Spring 2012 Fashion Week Fall 2012

      Featured

      Fashion Intern Tells All From Behind The Scenes At Two British Magazines Fashion Intern Tells All From Behind The Scenes At Two British Magazines
      Prada's Take On Ombre Prada's Take On Ombre
      The Intern Diaries: Behind The Scenes At A British Magazine The Intern Diaries: Behind The Scenes At A British Magazine
  • VIDEO
  • STYLELIST NETWORK

Blackface on 'America's Next Top Model'

by Laura Kenney (Subscribe to Laura Kenney's posts)
Posted Oct 29th 2009 at 1:15AM  
142 Comments
Share

Nicole Fox strikes a pose on "America's Next Top Model." Photo courtesy of The CW

Continuing the resurgence of a makeup practice long considered taboo, "America's Next Top Model" featured a number of models painted with dark makeup to resemble bi-racial women.

On the episode, which aired tonight (Oct. 28), host Tyra Banks said the goal was to create an editorial celebration of the "Hapa" (that's Hawaiian for mixed-race) children of immigrants who relocated to Hawaii to work as sugar cane farmers in the mid-19th century. Barack Obama is the most famous Hapa.

Banks tasked models with interpreting exotic racial combinations like "Russian-Moroccan," "Native American-East Indian," and "Botswanan-Polynesian," photographing them herself in the green reeds of a sugar plantation on the island of Maui.

http://xml.channel.aol.com/xmlpublisher/fetch.v2.xml?option=expand_relative_urls&dataUrlNodes=uiConfig,feedConfig,localizationConfig,entry&id=760784&pid=760783&uts=1256839468
http://www.aolcdn.com/ke/media_gallery/v1/ke_media_gallery_wrapper.swf
America's Next Top Model Controversy
See the transformation of the models in the America's Next Top Model episode in question
Ryan Goble, The CW

Americas Next Top Model, Bi-Racial

    Ryan Goble, The CW

    Ryan Goble, The CW

    Ryan Goble, The CW

    Ryan Goble, The CW

    Ryan Goble, The CW

    Ryan Goble, The CW

    Ryan Goble, The CW

    Ryan Goble, The CW

    Ryan Goble, The CW

    Ryan Goble, The CW


The models -- Jennifer An, Nicole Fox, Laura Kirkpatrick, Sundai Love, Brittany Markert and Erin Wagner -- were styled in clothing stereotypical to the ethnicities they were asked to portray. For example, Markert, who was "Native American-East Indian," was dressed in a feathered headdress and a sari. And Love, as a "Russian-Morrocan" was styled with Russian Ushanka hat and a large walking stick.

Then, the models were sent to makeup, where each was painted with varying degrees of dark body makeup to match the perceived skin tone of the corresponding race they were conveying.

This is the second time models have been shown in dark makeup in recent weeks.
French Vogue photographed model Lara Stone in blackface for its October issue, which was particularly disturbing because the offending pictures were part of an issue celebrating models, but had nary a black model in the magazine.

Instead, they chose to paint a blonde model black in a botched attempt to squeeze out a drop of artistic diversity.

Currently, out of "America's Next Top Model's" six remaining contestants, one is black, one is Asian and four are Caucasian. The show started out with four black models in a group of 14.

We asked experts to weigh in on the issue. Here's what they had to say:

Susan Stiffelman, Marriage and Family therapist and author of Parenting Without Power Struggles: "While the images shown on 'America's Top Model' were interesting and compelling, our culture is still quite young in terms of its ethnic maturity. Promoting women of color in traditional -- stereotypical -- attire and settings may have been motivated by a desire to celebrate diversity, but the photo shoot runs the risk of perpetuating stereotypes that women have long been working to dismantle.

"It's especially important to consider the effect on young women (the show's primary viewers) of having Caucasian models made up to simulate women of color, rather than having -- well, women of color being celebrated for their beauty. It could be considered a rather significant throwback to a time when people of African descent were excluded from mainstream theater and the arts, with white actors and performers substituted, with blackface.

Jennifer An in a headdress on "America's Next Top Model." Photo: Courtesy of The CW


"I would hope that a program that showcases the extraordinary beauty of women from every background would emphasize the beauty of each individual with the unique features, coloring and characteristics they were born with. This helps young girls and women embrace their own look, rather than fueling their desire to look like someone other than themselves."

Deborah Padilla, New York City Makeup Artist: "I think Tyra was using it as a platform to bring awareness to the issue, and not be offensive. There was an obvious theme. I thought she came up with a concept and executed it. The pictures were beautiful! But it's so easily for these things to get lost in translation.

"But I find it weird and question the motive of the photographer who shot the issue of French Vogue. The aim was to celebrate black models. So, why not use models of color? They are tons that are readily available. It's like a slap in the face. To not use black models and use blackface puts a different spin that makes it weird."

What do you think? Did you find this episode offensive? Was it in poor taste to feature models in dark makeup or was it all in the name of celebrating diversity? Take the poll, and leave a comment!
Read All Comments
Filed under: Beauty, News, Makeup
Tags: americas next top model, AmericasNextTopModel, blackface, hawaii, Tyra Banks, TyraBanks
Share

Style Around the Web

ImaxTree

ImaxTree

  • Make Up Tips For Girls With Glasses - Refinery29
  • How Celebs Work Red Into Their Wardrobe - FabSugar
  • Celebrity Wardrobe Malfunctions - The Daily Beast
  • Deodorants that Actually Work - Daily Candy
  • Would You Wear Long-Sleeve Shirts As Skirts? - The Frisky
  • Tricks That Guarantee Gorgeous Hair - Daily Makeover
  • Celebs Have Us Seeing Stars - People Style Watch

Related Videos

by 5min
  • Top Model Ends in Controversy Top Model Ends in Controversy Play Top Model had to re-shoot its finale after disqualifying one of the final three contestants.
  • America's Next Top Model: Winner Danielle Evans America's Next Top Model: Winner Danielle Evans Play Behind the scenes at America's Next Top Model winner Danielle Evans' ELLE shoot.
  • Top Model's Winner Whitney Thompson Blasts The Modeling Industry Top Model's Winner Whitney Thompson Blasts The Modeling Industry Play In an exclusive interview for Wetpaint, America's Next Top Model Cycle 10 winner Whitney Thompson dishes on sickly skinny girls, the airbrushing epidemic, and the shocking truth about the lies consumers are being sold.
  • From America's Next Top Model to Hung From America's Next Top Model to Hung Play By this point, every reality show worth talking about has featured at least one contestant who transcends the genre and become a bigger star than ever imagined. American Idol has Jennifer Hudson, Survivor has Elizabeth Hasselbeck, The Real World has Jamie Chung and America's Next Top Model has Analeigh Tipton. Although she placed third in cycle 11 of Tyra Banks' reality competition, she's gone on to star in The Green Hornett, this summer's Crazy Stupid Love and, currently, HBO's Hung.

READER COMMENTS

(142)Add A Comment

ebneila, 5-10-2011, 9:41PM

2 stars vote downvote upReport
ebneila

Until the mid sixties, the movie and TV medias used madeup Whites to portray ethnic groups. Few know that the famous "Amos 'n Andy" radio program scripts were read by White actors until the TV version opened up to Blacks. With the resurgence of racism rearing its ugly head, even in it's death throes, many media artist and producers still cannot let go. Why would someone use a White woman to portray a beautiful Black woman if it were not for racism? Black women can be found in every culture on Earth and cover a far greater range of ethic features and diversity than Whites. There is an apparent fear that exposing true beauty of Black women (and men) will supplant the standard of beauty Whites have established for themselves

Reply »

e, 5-10-2011, 9:47PM

2 stars vote downvote upReport
e

In my opinion, Black or White, no amount of makeup would make those pathetically thin chicks look good. They look more like clothes hangars than adult women

Reply »

Previous 20 Comments
 
ADD A COMMENT
  • NEW USER
  • RETURNING USERS
  • AOL/AIM USERS

Got something to say? Say it!

Simply enter your name and e-mail address, and you'll receive an email confirming your comment and issuing you a password. Use that password, and you're good to go.

If you already have an AOL/AIM screenname, log in under the other tabs.

Happy commenting, and keep it classy.

Members enter your username and password.

Enter your AOL or AIM screenname and password.

ADVERTISEMENT

STAY IN THE LOOP!

Most Popular

 
 
PHOTOS: Naomi Campbell's Long Hair Love Affair
Like

2

Billboard Music Awards Red Carpet 2012 (PHOTOS)
Like

79

Vanessa Williams' Poolside Glamour
Like

1

'Undercover Boss': 5 Most Gripping Moments From Season 3
Like

14

Peter Jones Dead: Crowded House Drummer Dies of Brain Cancer at 45
Like

653

PHOTOS: 27 Swimsuit Style Icons From The '40s To Today
Like

4

Why Facebook's Falling Share Price Really Doesn't Matter
Like

186

Mark Zuckerberg and Priscilla Chan: A Romantic Facebook Timeline
Like

122

Look Of The Day: Eva Mendes Is All Rosy
Like

11

After 37 Years, 'Neighbors From Hell' May Finally Face Eviction
Like

57

17 of the Riskiest Moves in Music History: The Brave, Crazy and Inspirational
Like

97

Goldie Hawn Looking Fierce In Leopard
Like

1

How I Paid Off $27,000 in Credit Card Debt in Two Years
Like

160

Kolmanskop: Namibia's Eerie Ghost Town
Like

8

PHOTOS: This Weekend In Manicures
Like

17

Rihanna Twitter Pictures: See the Singer's Most Shocking Social Media Photo Shares
Like

70

11 Pool-Proof Jewelry For Summer Fun
Like

4

Are These iPad Cases Or Clutches?
Like

9

The Trick To This Geometric Print Mani?
Like

25

Do You Use A Facespray Like This Yoga Instructor?
Like

1

Sarah Leon: PHOTOS: Why I Still Wear My Prom Dress
Like

20

Brie Dyas: How Joan Can Seduce Don Draper
Like

6

Hot on Facebook

 
 

MORE ON Stylelist

Leonardo Dicaprio House
Design Leonardo DiCaprio Malibu Beach House Pictures
Saucy Glossy Clutch
Stylelist Network The Perfect Summer Clutch: From The Stylelist Network
Overnight Guests
Know-How Getting Ready For Overnight Guests
Super Glue
Clean Home How To Clean And Remove Super Glue Stains From Any Surface
Clothes Pin Light
DIY Craft Of The Day: Make This Quirky Clothespin Chandelier
Porch Colors
Inspiration Enliven Your Porch With Color

SITES WE LOVE

A $1,000 Forever 21 Spree Will Add Some Pretty To Your Punk (Or Vice Versa)

Study The Hyperbalist's Sinful Eveningwear Philosophy

Prada's New Film: Ben Kingsley Falls For A Jacket, Roman Polanski Directs

Mary Kincaid: Weekly Roundup of eBay Vintage Clothing Finds (PHOTOS)

Felice Shapiro: Why Does The Media Care About Hilary's Glasses?

Lea Michele Shows Major Skin

Press Won’t Be Invited to Hedi Slimane’s First YSL Shows

Oscar de la Renta Shows Neon Hair Streaks, Gingham, and Gardenias for Resort

Best Bet: J Brand Floral Print Shorts

Shake Your Tassels: Nicholas Kirkwood Fringe Sandals

Fake Out: Rodial Brazilian Tan Face

Need For Beads: Alberta Ferretti Small Fabric Bag

Grab and Go: 25 Clutches to Get You Seasonally Chic Just in Time For Summer

The 10 Most Memorable Celebrity Fashion Gowns

Look of the Day: Metallic Ace

Mozart Meets the Future

‘Don Giovanni’ on Steroids

If Zuck Cleaned Up

EVEN MORE ON Stylelist

Design Destinations
Skin & Body
Gardening and Landscapes
Home Design
DIY STYLE
Beauty
Celebrity
Home Products
Minute Makeover
 
  • Terms of Service
  • Privacy Policy
  • Trademarks
  • Advertise
  • About Our Ads
  • Get AOL
 
 
© 2012 AOL Inc. All Rights Reserved