While vacationing in St. Barths over the new year, Lindsay Lohan managed to stand out even in a crowd full of models, socialites, and fellow actresses.

The super-skinny star kept her bikini on long after her beach day was over, wearing the tiny two-piece during a stroll through town, and even during a shopping trip with sister Ali that lasted all afternoon and continued past sunset.

Does throwing on a pair of platforms and wrapping a scarf around your neck really make a bikini into an outfit? Take a look at the photos and cast your vote!