Belgium Votes to Ban Burqas: Act of Public Safety or Suppression of Freedom?
MR party member Corinne De Permentier (top) during the vote against the wearing of the burka at the Belgian Federal parliament in Brussels on April 29, 2010. Photo: AFP/ Getty Images
Belgium 1, burqas 0.
Yesterday a bill to ban women from wearing burqa headveils in public passed almost unaminously in Belgium's parliament, making it the first European country to take legal action against the controversial Islamic garment, the Daily Mail reports.
Though the bill faces final approval from the country's senate, it could become law in July and would, as we've previously reported, mean fines and jail time for women caught wearing the veils in public, according to the paper.
Belgium politicians reportedly security concerns as the reason for the ban, as burqas conceal the face and make identification difficult. The law also applies to other garments that obscure the face.
"The notion of recognizing people in the street is essential to maintain public order," Centre-Right MP Daniel Bacquealaine told the paper.
"It's also a question of human dignity. The full face veil turns a woman into a walking prison."
Women caught violating the ban in public places such as hospitals, shops and schools will reportedly face a 15-25 euro fine for the first offense, and a week-long jail term if they fail to pay or are busted a second time.
Belgium -- which saw its prime minister, Yves Leterme, resign weeks ago in the midst of an earlier vote on the burqa -- isn't the only country taking action against the veil.
As we've reported previously, France is also considering a burqa ban.
But not everyone is applauding this move.
According to Sky News, Amnesty International has decried the ban, saying, "A complete ban on the covering of the face would violate the rights to freedom of expression and religion of those women who wear the burqa or the niqab."
"Today it's the full-face veil, tomorrow the veil, the day after it will be Sikh turbans and then perhaps it will be mini-skirts," added Isabelle Praile, vice-president of the Muslim Executive of Belgium.
What do you think? Do you think safety concerns trump individual freedom? Or is it a step too far? Take the poll, and leave a comment.
Meanwhile, read about Iran's crackdown on suntanned women.
Tags: amnesty international, belgium, burka, burkha, burqa, burqa ban, daniel bacquelaine, DanielBacquelaine, dress code, isabelle praile, islamic dress, muselim executive of belgium, muslim, veil






Lucky Islam Pataky, 4-30-2010, 5:12PM
As I understand it the burqas, hijabs and all other extreme covers were used for weather and climate reasons. Think about it - too much sand, dust and not enough water for hygiene or cleaning in those early days in Arabia deserts explain it well why people started covering their entire body including hair. Both the men and women grew long hair and they needed to protect their hair since waster was scarce in the desert. Notice that the men too cover themselves as women in Muslim culture. Somehow, the covering for women became a religious thing. Seriously, it makes no sense at all!
Have you seen those women who only cover their hair, and not the whole body. Have you noticed those covering only the hair with hijabs wearing heavy jewelries, makeup, and top of the line fashion outfit with name brand expensive accessories? I have seen heavy breasted women wearing stylish hijabs decorated with gems and fancy laces, covering only their hair, but not covering their luscious curves that men are prone to look at. I am sure these women do know that only covering their hair with hijabs won’t stop men from staring at their fashion accessorized curvy sexy bodies. So, it’s more like fashion or cultural than religious to me.
I want to see the verse in the Quran that says women to wear burqas or even the hijabs. I read that once a group of Muslim women were involved in running an entertainment business for men. They were bare breasted and wore sexually appealing outfit to lure men into their brothel like bars/clubs to spend money and have fun. These women were not respected very well by men those days (or the society) and were often beaten for not pleasing their clients. During that time, there was a verse established in the Quran that asked women should dress as such to cover their bare bodies to look sober and well respected. During that same time, drinking alcohol was also made Haraam (forbidden) for the Muslims.
Reply »