Catherine Zeta-Jones Scarlett Johansson

Catherine Zeta-Jones and Scarlett Johansson wear soft and pretty pastel eye makeup at the 2010 Tony Awards. Photos: Bryian Bedder/Getty Images (2)

While some of our favorite stars lit up The Great White Way last night with their glitzy fashion at the 2010 Tony Awards, two of Broadway's leading ladies stole the show in pastel eye makeup.

Catherine Zeta-Jones
and Scarlett Johansson shimmered in pretty eye shadows that made their peepers pop.

Zeta-Jones, who picked up the Tony Award for Best Performance by a Leading Actress in a Musical, rounded out her icy blue Versace gown and Lorraine Schwartz jewels with matching blue eye shadow, lush lashes, and glossy lips. The 40-year-old "A Little Night Music" star's lids were lined up to the brow in Elizabeth Arden's Color Intrigue Eyeshadow Duo in Peacock and dusted around the eyelashes with Color Intrigue Eyeshadow Duo in Black Currant -- bringing out the golden flecks of light in her brown eyes for a youthful look.

Johansson
added a refreshing contrast to her deep green, beaded Ellie Saab dress with well-blended pink and purple eye shadows framed by perfectly arched brows. Using Dolce & Gabbana The Make Up, makeup artist Gianpaolo Ceciliato swept the purple shadow from Smooth Eye Colour Duo in Dazzling, and the pink shadow from Smooth Eye Colour Duo in Guilty on the upper lids, while eyes were lined with Crayon Intense Eyeliner in Dahlia, a deep eggplant.

The Best Performance by a Featured Actress in a Play winner hit all the right marks by keeping the rest of her face neutral with soft cheeks and lips.

What do you think of Zeta-Jones and Johansson's pastel eye makeup?

Leave a comment below and be sure to check out more stars from the 2010 Tony Awards!