• Style
  • Women
  • Huff/Post50
  • Weddings
  • HealthyLiving
  • Divorce
  • Parents
  • Sign In / Register
  • stylelist home
  • huffpost style
  • FASHION
    • Departments

      Fashion News Fashion Features Fashion Trends Designers Models Accessories
      In The Market For Intern Diaries Step Into My Office Object of My Affection Stylelist Network Stories

      Featured

      Can You Guess The Child Model's Famous Aunt? Can You Guess The Child Model's Famous Aunt?
      Vintage-Obsessed Blogger Shares 18 Recent Finds Vintage-Obsessed Blogger Shares 18 Recent Finds
      Pinterest Cracks Down On Thinspirational Images Pinterest Cracks Down On Thinspirational Images
  • BEAUTY
    • Departments

      Beauty Basics Beauty News Beauty Features Beauty Trends Uptown Downtown Makeup Healthy Beautiful You
      Skin & Body Fragrance Nails Facetime The Unexpected Icon

      Featured

      This Student Reveals Her Bright-But-Wearable Pink Lipstick Shade This Student Reveals Her Bright-But-Wearable Pink Lipstick Shade
      Do You Use A Facespray Like This Yoga Instructor? Do You Use A Facespray Like This Yoga Instructor?
      Morgan Spurlock Waxes Philosophical On Mantyhose & Manscaping Morgan Spurlock Waxes Philosophical On Mantyhose & Manscaping
  • HAIR
    • Departments

      Hair Trends Hair How To

      Featured

      The Hair Doctor Is in: Consultation Is Key The Hair Doctor Is in: Consultation Is Key
      Guess Which Beauty Treatment She Gave The President Guess Which Beauty Treatment She Gave The President
      Can Pink Hair Look Sophisticated? Can Pink Hair Look Sophisticated?
  • CELEBRITY
    • Departments

      Style Evolution Look Of The Day Uptown|Downtown A Look Back

      Featured

      How Donna Summer Helped Me Through College How Donna Summer Helped Me Through College
      PHOTOS: Cameron Diaz's Life In 54 Looks PHOTOS: Cameron Diaz's Life In 54 Looks
      PHOTOS: 27 Stars Who Look More Beautiful Without Makeup PHOTOS: 27 Stars Who Look More Beautiful Without Makeup
  • CULTURE
    • Departments

      Art & Design Film Music Books & Magazines

      Featured

      How Long Does It Take To Become Mrs. Don Draper? How Long Does It Take To Become Mrs. Don Draper?
      5 Things This Hot New Musician Can't Live Without 5 Things This Hot New Musician Can't Live Without
      PHOTOS: SXSW Street Style PHOTOS: SXSW Street Style
  • FASHION WEEK
    • Departments

      Fashion Week Spring 2012 Fashion Week Fall 2012

      Featured

      Fashion Intern Tells All From Behind The Scenes At Two British Magazines Fashion Intern Tells All From Behind The Scenes At Two British Magazines
      Prada's Take On Ombre Prada's Take On Ombre
      The Intern Diaries: Behind The Scenes At A British Magazine The Intern Diaries: Behind The Scenes At A British Magazine
  • VIDEO
  • STYLELIST NETWORK


'America's Next Top Model': Shockingly Skinny Model Stars in Video Clip - Is This a Sick Joke?

by Erin Donnelly (Subscribe to Erin Donnelly's posts)
Posted Aug 11th 2010 at 10:45AM  
239 Comments
Share

"ANTM" model wannabe Ann and her "world's smallest" waist.

Tyra Banks has really outdone herself this time.

In a new trailer promoting the 15th cycle of "America's Next Top Model," Banks seems out to shock when she fawns over a 6'2" model wannabe named Ann who is so alarmingly skinny we literally gasped while watching the clip.

"There's something about her I like," squeals the normally pro-curves Banks about the catwalker, who claims to have the smallest waist in the world (no argument here).

Okay, so that's the fashion world's reaction...

Our reaction, if we saw this stick-thin waif on the street? We'd grab her, drag her to the nearest Denny's, and force one Grand Slam breakfast after another down her throat. But that's just us.

So, is Miss Tyra just trying to stir up some controversy to keep things fresh? Last season she pushed the envelope by having contestants wear "blackface" for a biracial-themed photo shoot.

Banks later apologized for the poorly received stunt, but there's no denying that it helped the show make headlines. And while the show has featured a number of plus-size models and "unconventional" contestants (blind, transgender, Asperger's, you name it), those stories had an inspirational, defying-the-odds slant.

Not so inspirational? Seeing judges drool (or pretend to drool) over a skeletal girl in an industry that already worships unrealistic size zero frames.

And though we've argued in the past that it's unfair to cast thin models as unhealthy, just as it's unfair to assume that a plus-size model is one Big Mac away from a heart attack, and that some people are just naturally skinny, if Ann is 6'2" it seems unlikely that she's anywhere near the healthy weight for her height. She makes a Photoshopped Ralph Lauren model look like Beth Ditto.

The past year has seen some major ups and downs in terms of body image.

Yes, plus-size model Crystal Renn walked the Chanel Resort runway... only to be virtually slimmed down in a photo shoot soon after.

Yes, fashion designers have proposed health regulations and age restrictions to help crack down on underweight models... while plus-size retailer Lane Bryant gets censored for daring to put a curvy bra-clad model in a prime-time ad.

Yes, "larger" (read: no protruding ribs) supermodels like Lara Stone and Coco Rocha are enjoying good exposure... but they are still all too rare on the runway.

And yes, Banks has been supportive of curvy gals in the past, but with this clip she seems to be following the bad example set by a few of her international "Next Top Model" peers.

For starters, in January "Australia's Next Top Model" judge Charlotte Dawson claimed that it was "tokenism" to cast plus-size models on the show, quipping that they'd at best get a gig modeling for Target. (Um, not too shabby.)

And just two months ago fashion designer and new "Britain's Next Top Model" judge Julien Macdonald called curvy models a "joke."

Were those comments despicable? Yes. Did they drum up publicity for the shows? Yes. Does it look like Tyra took notes? Hell yes.

It's a pity, not just for us "real-sized" women, but also for ultra-skinny girls like Ann who are being glorified for their unrealistic figures instead of getting the help -- and all-you-can-eat buffet -- they might need.

Oh, and Tyra... We were looking forward to the launch of your beauty and fashion site, but if, as the clip suggests, your idea of beauty is living on Tic Tacs and watercress, we'll pass.

What do you think of the ultra-skinny model in the clip and Tyra's choice to promote her? Leave a comment!

Meanwhile, Marc Jacobs is reportedly set to offer plus sizes.

Read All Comments
Filed under: Fashion, Beauty, Celebrity, News, Skin & Body
Tags: americas next top model, body image, charlotte dawson, julien macdonald, modeling competitions, models, plus size, publicity stunt, reality tv, size, size zero, skinny models, smallest waist, tyra banks, weight
Share

Style Around the Web

ImaxTree

ImaxTree

  • Make Up Tips For Girls With Glasses - Refinery29
  • How Celebs Work Red Into Their Wardrobe - FabSugar
  • Celebrity Wardrobe Malfunctions - The Daily Beast
  • Deodorants that Actually Work - Daily Candy
  • Would You Wear Long-Sleeve Shirts As Skirts? - The Frisky
  • Tricks That Guarantee Gorgeous Hair - Daily Makeover
  • Celebs Have Us Seeing Stars - People Style Watch

Related Videos

by 5min
  • Top Model's Winner Whitney Thompson Blasts The Modeling Industry Top Model's Winner Whitney Thompson Blasts The Modeling Industry Play In an exclusive interview for Wetpaint, America's Next Top Model Cycle 10 winner Whitney Thompson dishes on sickly skinny girls, the airbrushing epidemic, and the shocking truth about the lies consumers are being sold.
  • Israel Bans Underweight Models Israel Bans Underweight Models Play Israel has passed a law that bans underweight models. The law also requires advertisers to state whether their photos have been photoshopped.
  • Lindsay Lohan's Sister Denies Plastic Surgery Rumors Lindsay Lohan's Sister Denies Plastic Surgery Rumors Play Lindsay Lohan's little sister Aliana Lohan is getting a good laugh at the plastic surgery, alcohol and drug rumors swarming around her. Aliana, who is signed with Next Model Management, told Page Six Magazine that she's focusing on her career. Maureen Aladin has more.
  • Latest Celebrity Gossip Latest Celebrity Gossip Play Alessandra Ambrosio is expecting another child, Rachel Uchitel is expecting her first child, Ryan Reynolds and Blake Lively take the next step in their relationship, Snooki is skinny, and Giuliana Rancic is back to work after her double mastectomy all in today's celebrity gossip.

READER COMMENTS

(239)Add A Comment

cathy, 8-11-2010, 3:29PM

3 stars vote downvote upReport
cathy

I'd like to start by saying I DO NOT by any means, promote ultra thin, unheathy, and otherwise, diagnosed underweight models. I have to say I am a 5' 5", 113 lbs, 54 year old woman. I have been small all my life. I eat like a grown man. As a matter of fact, I eat more than my husband. He says that I live to eat; not eat to live. Everyone asks me "where does all that food go." I've tried every kind of weight gain drinks, food, and product.
I have been trying to gain weight for .... well all of my teen and adult life. It it equally frustrating trying to gain weight as it is trying to lose. I watch some of my freinds that are trying to lose weight get so frustrated as I do trying to gain. Some people just can not gain. I have been told it was in my DNA to be thin. After all these years, I still battle this weight gain situation.
I have watched America's Next Top Model and the Tyra Banks Show since they both started airing. As I observed the clip, I DO NOT think Tyra was promoting the thin weight on the model. Tyra is very facinated by "special" looks.. face, speech and mannerism. Also Mr. Jay mentioned the tic-tacs and watercress to Ms. Jay.
Tyra has help so many girls that I know with their self esteem and confidence. She even promotes curvy women. She is curvy herself. With all respect to you and not in a boastful way, I do believe that you miss judged Tyra's statement. I ask you to watch the clip again and then let me know if you feel differently
I just wanted to point these concerns out. Please do not be so quick to dismiss Tyra and her beauty and fashion site. If I am in error, I apologize. Thank you.

Reply »

Brittney, 8-12-2010, 11:29AM

3 stars vote downvote upReport
Brittney

I completely agree with you Cathy! Tyra is not only promoting a thin waist. She promotes diversity, uniqueness etc. If people actually watch the clip, they see she's just fascinated by the girl's "look" from head to toe. Just so happens that one of the girl's features is "the world's smallest waist" SO WHAT? no one would be complaining if Tyra was up there trying to give an obese person a career. People read into things WAY TOO MUCH these days.

»

Debrah, 8-12-2010, 11:55AM

2 stars vote downvote upReport
Debrah

Cathy, I don't think you were in error about Tyra's statement, at least not the meaning behind it. I'd guess that if Tyra could do it over, she wouldn't use those words. The long, tall model was fascinating to see (what little I could see of the clip); she was bizarre. In a bygone era, she might well have been featured in a traveling freak show. I'm not calling her one; I'm just saying what might have happened many years ago. But back to you, Cathy. At your height and weight, no doubt you look thin, but hardly anorexic. You don't realize how blessed you are, to be able to say that no matter how much you eat, you can't gain weight. You say that you get as frustrated as people who are trying to lose weight. Please don't say that; be frustrated about something else, because you don't know what you're talking about. I hate to say it, but having a very obese body is akin to having a physical deformity. Were you ever shunned and called hateful names as a child? Did you go to your high school prom? Did you have to wonder if anyone would be willing to take you, to be seen with you without being laughed at? I very much doubt it. There are always a few exceptions, which in my opinion, have a psychological component attached to them. But most straight men are attracted to a slim or average sized woman. The same is true for the reverse, but I'm sure there are more obese women than obese men. By their very nature, men don't gain weight as easily as women. There are many heavy women who will go with any man who looks in their direction, just so they can say they have someone. There is a woman at my job who is short and extremely obese who married a man who has been in prison more than once. He rarely works, so she is the breadwinner in a family of four. People know this and joke about it, or shake their heads in disgust. You say that you eat more than your husband, Cathy. But at least you do have a husband. There are some women who won't settle for the first bum that comes along. The sad result is that they spend their youth alone. I'm for raising the dress sizes of runway models from 0 to at least a size 6 or 8. This will probably happen when more women designers dominate the fashion world.

»

ChiefALot, 8-12-2010, 12:08PM

1 star vote downvote upReport
ChiefALot

I love em"

»

Christina, 8-12-2010, 3:37PM

3 stars vote downvote upReport
Christina

I think she either has a rare condition or she could have removed a rib. This doesn't look normal. When I was younger I remember being at a restaurant with my family and my father noticed a woman walk in the restaurant with a similar figure. My father made a joke at the table saying how her body looks like the shape of a wasp. If this girl, Ann, was born this way than more power to her to show the world what a "real woman" looks like. A "real woman" comes in all shapes and sizes. There is no standard size or standard shape of a woman. At one point skinny was in, then skinny is out and curvy is in, and vice versa. This should end! Our body shapes should never be "in" or "out"....it is not fashion. In this case, girls will not have plastic surgery to have butt implants, breast implants, stuff themselves in unhealthy ways to gain weight to look curvy and end up getting heart attacks and diabetes. AND...stop girls from starving themselves to look skinny. JUST EAT HEALTHY, keep portion sizes reasonable, exercise and be proud with the body you have. The media should show "healthy" woman of all shapes (hour-glass, pear-shaped, apple-shaped, square,etc) and sizes (naturally skinny, big boned, etc).

»

The Truth, 8-12-2010, 1:21PM

3 stars vote downvote upReport
The Truth

America's next top Bulemic is on a roll. It's obvious the female is skinny to a fault and one tic tac away from passing out.
Tyra is a pompous, cluelesss, dumbass created by a sector of society who thinks anything she represents really matters.
Show me someone who truly makes a difference by directing people to get real jobs that promote what's really important (Agriculture, healthcare, nutrition, teacher, Plumber, Electrician, Carpentry, etc) and we'll make them an example for others to follow.
Tyra and shows like hers do zero real good as they flit through life telling others if you don't look and act a certain way you're not relevant.
For all the money generated there's a whole lot of disappoiting heartbreak left in the wake while the greedy "one" gets rich.

»

Betty, 8-12-2010, 1:35PM

3 stars vote downvote upReport
Betty

If you keep watching the show progressivly adds more and more black girls in the contest.

Also, if Tyra loves her natural looks, why is it she wears blond wigs and uses colored contacts. Doesn't seem very natural to me

»

Paula, 4-07-2011, 8:39AM

2 stars vote downvote upReport
Paula

Cathy Im 5ft 3 and weigh 103 on a good day. I can eat what ever I want and not gain any weight. Some people are just made this way.

»

kati, 8-12-2010, 3:37PM

2.5 stars vote downvote upReport
kati

I am 5'11" and 115lbs. I've been skinny all my life. I am skinny BUT healthy. I gave birth to 3 very healthy 8 1/2lb baby boys. With each pregnancy I gained 40+lbs and lost it all within a year no diet or exercising. I have never been on a diet before. I eat some good food but a lot of junk food too (steak is my favorite food btw, ooh and stromboli!). Anyway I eat a **LOT** of food, my mom is skinny and her mom is skinny and her mom's mom etc etc. Some people just have a crazy-fast metabolism. I have to eat every 4hrs or I get lightheaded and dizzy, because my body burns food so quickly. That's the down side. That plus people always assume I don't eat or try to say I "need to gain weight" like it's easy - it's NOT! at least not for me. I'd be happier with 5 or even 10more lbs but whatever, no body is perfect and I am not going to worry about what other people think. Live for yourselves gals, not others. Take pride in what you have and enjoy.

»

G+3, 8-12-2010, 7:47PM

2.5 stars vote downvote upReport
G+3

Thanks so much for your comment. I get a little twitchy under the collar every time I read one of these articles that seems to think we should all ban together and force feed skinny people with one foot nailed to the floor.

I'm about you size too - I can gain but eat a lot and don't feel my best heavier.

I really want to respond to the comment below that asks if you've ever been "prejudiced" against. With a resounding YES! I've been made fun of in all the way you read in this article, i.e. go eat, looks like you haven't entired puberty, like a boy etc etc. It gets old.

AND, I want to add that while the first look at the girl is startling it is carefully choreographed - corset, black clothing, big guy behind her. She's 6'2; that means long long torso, which in turn means unless she's bloated she's going to have a really small middle. If you bother to look, her arms and legs looks average runway model. Her waist is by no means "smallest in the world" - remember when all women wore corsets, not to mention the fetish world of making the waist smaller and smaller - at least this is just her shape.

Don't hurl insults when you don't know the facts - she may be totally healthy. And by the way - no one removes ribs, ribs are what keep your waist IN.

I see this trend of skinny bashing more and more and I also see obesity more and more - not a good situation.

»

debra, 3-14-2011, 10:23PM

2 stars vote downvote upReport
debra

i'm still pissed off over the "petite model" series. 5ft 7 is not petite. 5 ft 3 and under is petite. petite clothes are chut shorter to fit short women, and 5 ft 7 is not petite.

that show is rigged. it becomes clear about half way who has been pre selected. seriously, whitney? she was always at the bottom, never improved, and any thin girl would have been bumped off for it.

hurry back with america's got talent. now there is a fun show.

»

ray, 8-11-2010, 2:19PM

3 stars vote downvote upReport
ray

pray tell what has your cheap attempt at spamming have to do with this article?

Reply »

JohnE, 8-11-2010, 2:37PM

2.5 stars vote downvote upReport
JohnE

uh...You'd have to take her to DENNYS if you wanted to (force) feed her the "Grand Slam" breakfasts...NOT IHOP!

Reply »

Non-skinny, 8-11-2010, 7:38PM

3 stars vote downvote upReport
Non-skinny

uhh thats what they said.........

»

Gia, 8-12-2010, 11:59AM

2 stars vote downvote upReport
Gia

Uh John...where did you see IHOP mentioned??

»

jolly, 8-11-2010, 2:37PM

3 stars vote downvote upReport
jolly

I am so sick of watching these "anorexic" models on TV. They should change the name to..." America's Next top anorexic model"! Why can't these girls EAT! This is setting a bad example for young women that want to become models. So when they see these skin and bones women, they are thinking that they have to be that thin to be a model. I love Tyra, but she is setting a BAD example here.

Reply »

jackie, 8-11-2010, 3:48PM

2.5 stars vote downvote upReport
jackie

fat girls can become models, but they can't be true top models or supermodels. that's a whole different standard.

»

kristina, 8-11-2010, 7:00PM

Half a star vote downvote upReport
kristina

i don't understand why you think it's okay to accuse thin people of not eating.. you're probably extremely overweight and jealous. you have such a problem with thin people and jump to conclusions about them being anorexic, yet you haven't said a word about the problem we have in our country with obesity (which affects MORE people than anorexia). you disgust me.

»

kk, 8-12-2010, 12:44PM

3 stars vote downvote upReport
kk

I don't understand why when someone accuses these models of not eating (which most don't) that someone else has to jump in and accuse them of being fat and jealous. It is what it is...Most don't eat as much as they should. I am sure there are some that can eat whatever they want, but that is the exception not the rule. I had a friend who modeled and I heard "wonderful" stories of swollowing cotton balls to feel full and not actually eat....

»

Maureen, 8-12-2010, 2:40PM

2 stars vote downvote upReport
Maureen

I agree with you Jolly. It is sad how alot of girls think this is the way a woman should look. I watched something on tv about if the classic stars were around today they wouldn't have a career they would be considered fat. I think they were timeless and beautiful. More so than some of these girls now. The women were natural normal looking not like they were in some camp during the holocaust.Hollywoods new size is 0 .There are some women that small but when a woman is 6 ft or you see this actresses get smaller and tht sunken eye look it is horrifying. I have a best friend whos daughter think she is fat and she was 13 in a childs 13 She thought the victoria secret models were fat. The modelling industry and people in charge need shock treatment .They do nothing but promot insecurity and eating disorders. So many women die from this.

»

| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Most Recent | Next 20 Comments
 
ADD A COMMENT
  • NEW USER
  • RETURNING USERS
  • AOL/AIM USERS

Got something to say? Say it!

Simply enter your name and e-mail address, and you'll receive an email confirming your comment and issuing you a password. Use that password, and you're good to go.

If you already have an AOL/AIM screenname, log in under the other tabs.

Happy commenting, and keep it classy.

Members enter your username and password.

Enter your AOL or AIM screenname and password.

ADVERTISEMENT

STAY IN THE LOOP!

Most Popular

 
 
WATCH: We Find The Real Difference Between LA & NY Street Style
Like

7

First Woman To Command A Warship In Royal Navy History
Like

338

PHOTOS: 54 Ultra-Chic Warm Weather Hairstyles
Like

35

'American Idol' Changes Record Contract Policy: Runner-Up No Longer Guaranteed Major Bucks
Like

117

The Richest Woman in the World: How Gina Rinehart Earns her Billions
Like

1K

C.Z. Guest's Unusual White Accessory
Like

13

America's 10 Highest-Paid CEOs of 2011 (and How They Earned It)
Like

883

What Happened When Alex Kenjeev Paid His Student Loan in Cash
Like

2K

Look Of The Day: Solange Gets Garden Party-Ready
Like

10

Samsung Galaxy S III review
Like

2K

Country Star Yearbook Pics
Like

55

Carrie Fisher's All Tied Up
Like

0

Hawkeye and the Blue Ear Help a Mother and Her Hearing Impaired Son
Like

2K

Safeway Worker Stops Man From Beating Pregnant Woman, Gets Suspended
Like

337

Leap Motion gesture control technology hands-on
Like

3K

Hot on Facebook

 
 

MORE ON Stylelist

Garden Tips
Gardening and Landscapes Your Garden Design Questions, Answered
Room Makeover
Know-How 3 Life-Changing Room Makeovers
Weekend Diys
DIY Weekend DIY Ideas: 8 Ways To Fix Up Your Home In 2 Days Or Less (PHOTOS)
Ray And The Ro Ksubi
Stylelist Network Ksubi 'Bad Sports' Lookbook: From The Stylelist Network
Memorial Day Sales
Projects Memorial Day Sales 2012: Home Decor And Outdoor Furniture Sales At Macy's, Sears, Home Depot And More (PHOTOS)
Pier Liautaud Home
Design Inside A Gorgeous '50s Style Home In Haiti (PHOTOS)

SITES WE LOVE

10 Cheap-Chic Pieces To Transform Your Closet

Eddie The Gun's Favorite '80s Accessory? Her Pup

Summer Survival Guide: 10 Essential Beauty Buys From Your D.C. Editor

PHOTOS: Nicole Scherzinger Almost Reveals Too Much

Tommy Smythe, Sarah Richardson's Sidekick, Gives Us His Top 5 Design Tips

Sexiest Fashion Week Ever?

Carine Roitfeld, Janet Jackson, Karl Lagerfeld, and More at Last Night’s amfAR Gala in Cannes

Natalia Vodianova Was Royal in Blue

Cathy Horyn Deems Mickey Drexler’s Life ‘Not the Stuff of Novels’

Scrub Down: Hadali Detoxifying Body Scrub

Dressed In White: Sophie Theallet Sea Island White Cotton Gown

Patriotic Purse: Edie Parker Red, White and Blue Jean Clutch

Heat It Up: 5 Cool Outfits Inspired by Our Favorite Summer Movies

One Awesome Thing: A Swimsuit to Make You Feel Like a Bond Girl

Look of the Day: Leopard Meets Brights

Kim Kardashian a Kopy Kat?

Priscilla Chan’s Wedding Secret

Mozart Meets the Future

EVEN MORE ON Stylelist

Clean Home
Beauty
Inspiration
Home Design
Beauty Basics
Hair Highlights
 
  • Terms of Service
  • Privacy Policy
  • Trademarks
  • Advertise
  • About Our Ads
  • Get AOL
 
 
© 2012 AOL Inc. All Rights Reserved