
'America's Next Top Model': Shockingly Skinny Model Stars in Video Clip - Is This a Sick Joke?
"ANTM" model wannabe Ann and her "world's smallest" waist.
In a new trailer promoting the 15th cycle of "America's Next Top Model," Banks seems out to shock when she fawns over a 6'2" model wannabe named Ann who is so alarmingly skinny we literally gasped while watching the clip.
"There's something about her I like," squeals the normally pro-curves Banks about the catwalker, who claims to have the smallest waist in the world (no argument here).
Okay, so that's the fashion world's reaction...
Our reaction, if we saw this stick-thin waif on the street? We'd grab her, drag her to the nearest Denny's, and force one Grand Slam breakfast after another down her throat. But that's just us.
So, is Miss Tyra just trying to stir up some controversy to keep things fresh? Last season she pushed the envelope by having contestants wear "blackface" for a biracial-themed photo shoot.
Banks later apologized for the poorly received stunt, but there's no denying that it helped the show make headlines. And while the show has featured a number of plus-size models and "unconventional" contestants (blind, transgender, Asperger's, you name it), those stories had an inspirational, defying-the-odds slant.
Not so inspirational? Seeing judges drool (or pretend to drool) over a skeletal girl in an industry that already worships unrealistic size zero frames.
And though we've argued in the past that it's unfair to cast thin models as unhealthy, just as it's unfair to assume that a plus-size model is one Big Mac away from a heart attack, and that some people are just naturally skinny, if Ann is 6'2" it seems unlikely that she's anywhere near the healthy weight for her height. She makes a Photoshopped Ralph Lauren model look like Beth Ditto.
The past year has seen some major ups and downs in terms of body image.
Yes, plus-size model Crystal Renn walked the Chanel Resort runway... only to be virtually slimmed down in a photo shoot soon after.
Yes, fashion designers have proposed health regulations and age restrictions to help crack down on underweight models... while plus-size retailer Lane Bryant gets censored for daring to put a curvy bra-clad model in a prime-time ad.
Yes, "larger" (read: no protruding ribs) supermodels like Lara Stone and Coco Rocha are enjoying good exposure... but they are still all too rare on the runway.
And yes, Banks has been supportive of curvy gals in the past, but with this clip she seems to be following the bad example set by a few of her international "Next Top Model" peers.
For starters, in January "Australia's Next Top Model" judge Charlotte Dawson claimed that it was "tokenism" to cast plus-size models on the show, quipping that they'd at best get a gig modeling for Target. (Um, not too shabby.)
And just two months ago fashion designer and new "Britain's Next Top Model" judge Julien Macdonald called curvy models a "joke."
Were those comments despicable? Yes. Did they drum up publicity for the shows? Yes. Does it look like Tyra took notes? Hell yes.
It's a pity, not just for us "real-sized" women, but also for ultra-skinny girls like Ann who are being glorified for their unrealistic figures instead of getting the help -- and all-you-can-eat buffet -- they might need.
Oh, and Tyra... We were looking forward to the launch of your beauty and fashion site, but if, as the clip suggests, your idea of beauty is living on Tic Tacs and watercress, we'll pass.
What do you think of the ultra-skinny model in the clip and Tyra's choice to promote her? Leave a comment!
Meanwhile, Marc Jacobs is reportedly set to offer plus sizes.
Tags: americas next top model, body image, charlotte dawson, julien macdonald, modeling competitions, models, plus size, publicity stunt, reality tv, size, size zero, skinny models, smallest waist, tyra banks, weight






cathy, 8-11-2010, 3:29PM
I'd like to start by saying I DO NOT by any means, promote ultra thin, unheathy, and otherwise, diagnosed underweight models. I have to say I am a 5' 5", 113 lbs, 54 year old woman. I have been small all my life. I eat like a grown man. As a matter of fact, I eat more than my husband. He says that I live to eat; not eat to live. Everyone asks me "where does all that food go." I've tried every kind of weight gain drinks, food, and product.
I have been trying to gain weight for .... well all of my teen and adult life. It it equally frustrating trying to gain weight as it is trying to lose. I watch some of my freinds that are trying to lose weight get so frustrated as I do trying to gain. Some people just can not gain. I have been told it was in my DNA to be thin. After all these years, I still battle this weight gain situation.
I have watched America's Next Top Model and the Tyra Banks Show since they both started airing. As I observed the clip, I DO NOT think Tyra was promoting the thin weight on the model. Tyra is very facinated by "special" looks.. face, speech and mannerism. Also Mr. Jay mentioned the tic-tacs and watercress to Ms. Jay.
Tyra has help so many girls that I know with their self esteem and confidence. She even promotes curvy women. She is curvy herself. With all respect to you and not in a boastful way, I do believe that you miss judged Tyra's statement. I ask you to watch the clip again and then let me know if you feel differently
I just wanted to point these concerns out. Please do not be so quick to dismiss Tyra and her beauty and fashion site. If I am in error, I apologize. Thank you.
Reply »