• Style
  • Women
  • Huff/Post50
  • Weddings
  • HealthyLiving
  • Divorce
  • Parents
  • Sign In / Register
  • stylelist home
  • huffpost style
  • FASHION
    • Departments

      Fashion News Fashion Features Fashion Trends Designers Models Accessories
      In The Market For Intern Diaries Step Into My Office Object of My Affection Stylelist Network Stories

      Featured

      Can You Guess The Child Model's Famous Aunt? Can You Guess The Child Model's Famous Aunt?
      Vintage-Obsessed Blogger Shares 18 Recent Finds Vintage-Obsessed Blogger Shares 18 Recent Finds
      Pinterest Cracks Down On Thinspirational Images Pinterest Cracks Down On Thinspirational Images
  • BEAUTY
    • Departments

      Beauty Basics Beauty News Beauty Features Beauty Trends Uptown Downtown Makeup Healthy Beautiful You
      Skin & Body Fragrance Nails Facetime The Unexpected Icon

      Featured

      This Student Reveals Her Bright-But-Wearable Pink Lipstick Shade This Student Reveals Her Bright-But-Wearable Pink Lipstick Shade
      Do You Use A Facespray Like This Yoga Instructor? Do You Use A Facespray Like This Yoga Instructor?
      Morgan Spurlock Waxes Philosophical On Mantyhose & Manscaping Morgan Spurlock Waxes Philosophical On Mantyhose & Manscaping
  • HAIR
    • Departments

      Hair Trends Hair How To

      Featured

      The Hair Doctor Is in: Consultation Is Key The Hair Doctor Is in: Consultation Is Key
      Guess Which Beauty Treatment She Gave The President Guess Which Beauty Treatment She Gave The President
      Can Pink Hair Look Sophisticated? Can Pink Hair Look Sophisticated?
  • CELEBRITY
    • Departments

      Style Evolution Look Of The Day Uptown|Downtown A Look Back

      Featured

      How Donna Summer Helped Me Through College How Donna Summer Helped Me Through College
      PHOTOS: Cameron Diaz's Life In 54 Looks PHOTOS: Cameron Diaz's Life In 54 Looks
      PHOTOS: 27 Stars Who Look More Beautiful Without Makeup PHOTOS: 27 Stars Who Look More Beautiful Without Makeup
  • CULTURE
    • Departments

      Art & Design Film Music Books & Magazines

      Featured

      How Long Does It Take To Become Mrs. Don Draper? How Long Does It Take To Become Mrs. Don Draper?
      5 Things This Hot New Musician Can't Live Without 5 Things This Hot New Musician Can't Live Without
      PHOTOS: SXSW Street Style PHOTOS: SXSW Street Style
  • FASHION WEEK
    • Departments

      Fashion Week Spring 2012 Fashion Week Fall 2012

      Featured

      Fashion Intern Tells All From Behind The Scenes At Two British Magazines Fashion Intern Tells All From Behind The Scenes At Two British Magazines
      Prada's Take On Ombre Prada's Take On Ombre
      The Intern Diaries: Behind The Scenes At A British Magazine The Intern Diaries: Behind The Scenes At A British Magazine
  • VIDEO
  • STYLELIST NETWORK


Payless Over the Knee Boots - Testing the Garment

by Lindsey Schickner (Subscribe to Lindsey Schickner's posts)
Posted Oct 25th 2010 at 7:25PM  
12 Comments
Share
http://xml.channel.aol.com/xmlpublisher/fetch.v2.xml?option=expand_relative_urls&dataUrlNodes=uiConfig,feedConfig,localizationConfig,entry&id=948411&pid=948410&uts=1288203243
http://www.aolcdn.com/ke/media_gallery/v1/ke_media_gallery_wrapper.swf
Real Women Wear - Payless Over the Knee Boots
Seven women from across the country went to the their local Payless, tried on these over the knee boots, and reported back to StyleList. Find out what their experience was with the fall footwear trend and whether or not they would buy them.
Nana-Adwoa

Real Women Wear - Payless Over the Knee Boots

Name: Sylvia Colette Branch
From: Cleveland, IL
Age: 40
Body type: Classic hourglass figure
Personal style: Comfortable classics paired with a funky accessory.

How do you feel?
The boots were amazing. I felt like I was wearing thick, tall socks.

How is the fit?
The long, straight lines did the same thing a pair of leggings or knit tights would do; cover and provide camouflage for my legs.

How is the material?
The faux suede was soft and extremely flexible.

Where would you wear them?
Any event that required lots of walking in place of a pair of heeled boots.

What types of outfits would you wear them with?
These pair well with skirts and dresses.

Are the boots easy to get on and off and seem comfortable to walk in?
The partial side zipper makes getting in and out of these boots much easier than I expected. I did have to go up a shoe size, but that is typical in my experience with Payless shoes.

How often would you wear them?
I can see myself wearing these boots often.

Would you buy them?
Definitely.

Real Women Wear - Payless Over the Knee Boots

Name: Natasha Holstine
From: Tucson, AZ
Age: 28
Blog: Fashionalities
Body type: Pear shape
Personal style: Eclectic-mixing vintage with high fashion pieces.

How do you feel?
I am excited the boots actually went over my calves but, I'm not sure if they are right for me.

How is the fit?
I like that they are flat since I am a new mommy and the winter is approaching but, on a fashionista side I feel kind of squatty.

How is the material?
Less appealing up close but overall pretty good. I like they won't be ruined easily from water contact either.

Where would you wear them?
Casual days and weekends.

What types of outfits would you wear them with?
I would pair them with skinny jeans or leggings and a tunic top. I don't see this style boot being flattering with a dress on my body.

Are the boots easy to get on and off and seem comfortable to walk in?
I actually had a panic attack at the store with the right foot. Both sides went on easily, but the right foot took a little maneuvering to get off.

How often would you wear them?
I think I could wear these a lot during the fall/winter.

Would you buy them?
For the price, I actually did. At $25 and a 20% coupon you can't pass it up.

Real Women Wear - Payless Over the Knee Boots

Name: Kate Pesich
From: Louisiana
Age: 27
Body type: Classic and curvy
Personal style: Classic but also drawing from each season's new color and print motifs.

How do you feel?
In this pair of boots I feel like I'm ready to take on the town. They're sophisticated enough to pair with skirts and dresses, but casual enough to walk a mile or two in if I've got somewhere to be.

How is the fit?
The fit is fabulous--I have very muscular calves that fill them out nicely.

How is the material?
The material is surprisingly well-made for faux suede. It's got plenty of give so my legs can breathe when worn pulled straight over the knee and has a natural slouch when the top of the boot is folded over.

Where would you wear them?
Just about anywhere. They're flat so they don't kill my feet, and also add leg-cover to a short and sassy sweater dress.

What types of outfits would you wear them with?I'm currently on the lookout for the perfect sweater-dress to compliment them.

Are the boots easy to get on and off and seem comfortable to walk in?
They're the easiest to get on over-the-knee boot I've ever worn. The side zipper is great for pulling down skinny jeans to ensure they stay tucked in. The top of the boot looks fabulous whether I pull it up straight or fold it over, so they're versatile enough to wear with leggings and dresses.

How often would you wear them?
A few times a week.

Would you buy them?
I did, and I don't regret my decision.

Real Women Wear - Payless Over the Knee Boots

Name: Rosemary Ebertfrom
From: Coopersburg, PA
Blog: Momperks
Body type: Not pencil thin.
Personal style: Comfy and easy but stylish and current.

How do you feel?
As soon as I slid them on, I felt like I was calling attention to all the areas I would rather keep hidden.

How is the fit?
The size was correct but the way the boots fit in the foot area was extremely narrow. I had no problem fitting them over my jeans.

What types of outfits would you wear them with?I tried them on with a pair of skinny jeans and a loose fitting off-the-shoulder top.

Are the boots easy to get on and off and seem comfortable to walk in?
I could not slide them on. The one boot was such a problem to get on that I had to leave it unzipped in the pictures.

Would you buy them?
They would look adorable on someone younger, with a black mini and an embellished shouldered top...just not for me.

Real Women Wear - Payless Over the Knee Boots

Name: Nana-Adwoa Ofori
From: New York City
Age: 33
Blog: Nightly Candy with Nana-Adwoa
Body type: I stand at 5"2 and I am proud of every inch.
Personal style: Vintage-inspired.

How do you feel?
There is so little cushioning at the base of the feet. I felt like my feet were too close to the concrete.

How is the fit?
The "over the knee" boot is popular this fall. I applaud Payless for making the effort to stay on trend however, these boots don't exactly make it "over" my knees. It would have been great if they added more fabric and had constructed the boot to fold over.

How is the material?
I wasn't thrilled with the material.

Where would you wear them?
I would wear these boots on a regular night out where I know I will be taking a cab there and back.

What types of outfits would you wear them with?
I would wear some funky printed leggings, a solid colored dress, and cropped jacket to complete the look.

How often would you wear them?
Once in a blue moon.

Would you buy them?
Do I love the look? Unfortunately not, so am going to have to pass.

Real Women Wear - Payless Over the Knee Boots

Name: Wendy Rose Gould
From: Phoenix, AZ.
Age: 24
Body type: Hourglass shape -- somewhat short with a tiny waist and a bigger bottom.
Personal style: A cross between girly kitsch and bohemian.

How do you feel?
They fit really well but I'm not used to wearing such tall boots, so I felt a little uncomfortable.

How is the fit?
I have really short legs and, in my opinion, the boots make them feel shorter. I definitely didn't feel self conscious, though.

How is the material?
The material and construction was surprisingly above par. These are right up there with the higher quality purchases I've made.

Where would you wear them?
On a crisp afternoon out shopping or errands.

What types of outfits would you wear them with?I think jeans, jeggings or leggings are a must with these shoes. I'd pair them with a cute top, perhaps an over sized sweater or cardigan, and some giant sunglasses.

Are the boots easy to get on and off and seem comfortable to walk in?
My husband actually trekked to Payless with me on this one, and he found my struggles to get the boots on quite amusing! I had to go up a size and I still struggled a bit. Maybe it's because I'm used to sliding on flats?

How often would you wear them?
Every once in a while. They're slightly high maintenance for my taste.

Would you buy them?
If they went on sale even further (now at $39), I would definitely consider it.

Real Women Wear - Payless Over the Knee Boots

Name: Patrice Yursik
From: Chicago, IL
Age: 31
Blog: Afrobella
Body type: Full-figured
Personal style: Young, fun and cool

How do you feel? Uncomfortable and disappointed. These boots won't fit my calves, which is an issue in itself. But one of the boots literally won't zip down, and sadly at this Payless they don't have another pair I can try on.

How is the fit?
Definitely self conscious right now. But if these bad boys fit and zipped as they should, I might have walked out of the store with them! They are super cute.

How is the material?
They're made of a thin suede and the soles don't feel especially durable. I have to think about stuff like that, living in Chicago and facing winter soon.

Where would you wear them?
If they fit? Out for cocktails or on a sexy date night.

What types of outfits would you wear them with?
The boots are begging for jeggings or for a cute swingy dress.

Are the boots easy to get on and off and seem comfortable to walk in?
Easy to get off, impossible to get on. I also have concerns about the zip - even if they fit me, that'd be a potential issue. Still, I wish they made these in a wide calf version - I know so many plus size fashionistas looking for affordable OTK boots!

How often would you wear them?
I think I could wear these a lot during the fall/winter.

Would you buy them?
No, sad to say.

Real Women Wear - Payless Over the Knee Boots



Given that women come in different shapes and sizes, it can be hard to find the perfect pair of boots for our legshape. And now that it's fall, the time to select that all important footwear that is both fancy and functional is upon us.

Over the knee boots have gained momentum, but while outré styles are perfect for the runway, how do they translate for real women with shorter or wider legs?

For our this week's testing the garment segment, we decided to send our merry band of fashion reviewers to Payless to find out if the Madge Flat Over the Knee Boots are universally alluring or better sitting pretty on the shelf.

As per the custom, the savvy shoppers (some of whom are bloggers, while others are not) headed to their local shopping mall to try on these reasonably priced ($59.99) kickers. The overall consensus? Whether pulled over opaque tights or worn with skinny jeans these saucy shoes proved to be a bit of a challenge for our reviewers.

But don't take our word for it. Find out what these women, who are of varying style and body types, had to say about size, fit, and fabrication as it pertains to these super boots.

Make sure to enlarge the gallery to full-screen -- and let us know if you're a fan of the style of these boots by leaving a comment.

For simple fall pieces to wear with your super stylish shoes, check out how to wear the minimalist trend.
Read All Comments
Filed under: Accessories, Fashion, Best of the Season, How to Wear, Shopping
Tags: fall boots, fall shoes, FallBoots, FallShoes, over the knee boots, OverTheKneeBoots, payless, style council, StyleCouncil
Share

Style Around the Web

ImaxTree

ImaxTree

  • Make Up Tips For Girls With Glasses - Refinery29
  • How Celebs Work Red Into Their Wardrobe - FabSugar
  • Celebrity Wardrobe Malfunctions - The Daily Beast
  • Deodorants that Actually Work - Daily Candy
  • Would You Wear Long-Sleeve Shirts As Skirts? - The Frisky
  • Tricks That Guarantee Gorgeous Hair - Daily Makeover
  • Celebs Have Us Seeing Stars - People Style Watch

Related Videos

by 5min
  • How to Wear Knee High Boots How to Wear Knee High Boots Play This is your guide to wearing knee high boots according to your body shape and with the right accessories.
  • How to Wear Ankle Boots How to Wear Ankle Boots Play This video jug film by Claire Wacey gives fashion tips for those who want to wear boots during the autumn and winter seasons. Ms. Wacey shows a variety of boots such as shoe boots, ankle boots, and knee-high boots. She gives advice on boots appropriate for leg size and gives clothing suggestions for each boot type.
  • Tips for Wearing Leggings Tips for Wearing Leggings Play Learn how to wear leggings and look fashionable with these tips.
  • How to Make a Skirt out of a Jeans Trousers How to Make a Skirt out of a Jeans Trousers Play This knee length denim skirt is both flirty & comfortable. Wear with boots for a sexy look or with flip flops for casual days. Distributed by Tubemogul.

READER COMMENTS

(12)Add A Comment

Melanie, 10-28-2010, 11:48AM

2.5 stars vote downvote upReport
Melanie

Absolutely hideous!!!

Reply »

Heather, 10-28-2010, 11:51AM

2 stars vote downvote upReport
Heather

Dear editor (and future editors),
Please stop using the term "real women"! It is idiotic to even suggest that one type of woman is more "womanly" than another.
Good day.

Reply »

rkniolek, 10-28-2010, 12:01PM

2.5 stars vote downvote upReport
rkniolek

60 bucks is not reasonable, i guess i will have to wait until they go on sale as usual

Reply »

maggie, 10-28-2010, 12:29PM

2 stars vote downvote upReport
maggie

Oh no! Send these beautiful ladies some help....outfits all put together wrong. Plus not smiling, doing your best to show how unhappy you are and just not having fun with trying something new doesn't do anything justice whether it's right or not for that person.
Bring a friend that has some sense of how to put things together because they obviously don't or just didn't go into this with an open mind.

Reply »

khs, 10-28-2010, 12:47PM

2.5 stars vote downvote upReport
khs

"Yes I am a pirate, two hundred years too late"

Reply »

cgw, 10-28-2010, 12:27PM

2 stars vote downvote upReport
cgw

Unless you are a pirate or a hooker, these things look ridiculous.

Reply »

LST, 10-28-2010, 1:04PM

2 stars vote downvote upReport
LST

I guess they would look fine on a hooker, LOL!

Reply »

notallhere, 10-28-2010, 2:41PM

2 stars vote downvote upReport
notallhere

Those boots are ugly. If I were going to wear over-the-knee boots, I would buy a more high dollar pair. You do not want to buy cheap over-the-knee boots. The cheap look of them only adds to the hooker effect.

Reply »

Gail, 10-28-2010, 3:14PM

2 stars vote downvote upReport
Gail

Those boots didn't look right on any of your "real" women. A big ICK! from me.

Reply »

Nirvana, 12-03-2010, 1:37PM

2 stars vote downvote upReport
Nirvana

These boots have to be coordinated carefully in order to look good. I've seen these best paired with cropped jackets and sweaters.

Reply »

fashion women shoes, 8-15-2011, 4:11AM

2 stars vote downvote upReport
fashion women shoes

Its like you read my mind! You appear to know so much about this, like you wrote the book in it or something. I think that you could do with some pics

Reply »

http:ladiesfashionshoes.blogspot.com, 8-15-2011, 4:10AM

2 stars vote downvote upReport
http:ladiesfashionshoes.blogspot.com

Thank you for the good writeup. It in fact was a amusement account it. Look advanced to far added agreeable from you! By the way, how could we communicate?

Reply »

 
ADD A COMMENT
  • NEW USER
  • RETURNING USERS
  • AOL/AIM USERS

Got something to say? Say it!

Simply enter your name and e-mail address, and you'll receive an email confirming your comment and issuing you a password. Use that password, and you're good to go.

If you already have an AOL/AIM screenname, log in under the other tabs.

Happy commenting, and keep it classy.

Members enter your username and password.

Enter your AOL or AIM screenname and password.

ADVERTISEMENT

STAY IN THE LOOP!

ONLY ON STYLELIST

Sunscreen Dangerous? Experts Shed Light on the Controversy
Beauty
Healthy Beautiful You
Should you be afraid of sunscreen? From natural to chemical to Vitamin A, our experts explain and advise just...
Beauty BasicsMom MakeoversMore Beauty Tips »
Reese Witherspoon's Retro Waves: How to Get the Look!
Hair
Hair Basics
Reese Witherspoon goes retro on the May 2011 cover of Vogue with glamorous '40s-era hair. And we've got pro...
Haircuts by FaceMore Hair Help »
Sample Sale Snitch | Proenza Schouler SS 11
Fashion
Spring
Check out some discounted duds from Proenza today and tomorrow.
Style GuideStyle by BodyMore Fashion Tips »
Look of the Day: Aubrey Plaza & Amy Poehler at the Premiere of
Celebrity
Look of the Day
Both ladies opted for fun, printed frocks -- but each styled their looks much differently.
Look for LessMore Celebrity Tips »

MORE ON Stylelist

Outdoor Decor
Inspiration Create A Getaway Feel For Your Backyard, Patio Or Balcony
City Gardening
Gardening and Landscapes Tips For Growing A Garden In A City
Room Makeover
Know-How 3 Life-Changing Room Makeovers
Weekend Diys
DIY Weekend DIY Ideas: 8 Ways To Fix Up Your Home In 2 Days Or Less (PHOTOS)
Ray And The Ro Ksubi
Stylelist Network Ksubi 'Bad Sports' Lookbook: From The Stylelist Network
Memorial Day Sales
Projects Memorial Day Sales 2012: Home Decor And Outdoor Furniture Sales At Macy's, Sears, Home Depot And More (PHOTOS)

SITES WE LOVE

Meet Fashion's Coolest Moonlighters — & See How They Make It Work

Headphone Stalking! 9 Rad 'Phones From The NY Streets

5 Outfits To Try This Week: Sneakers, Overalls, & More

Jeanine Celeste Pang: Reinventing Happily Ever After

Get Jordin's Lacy Look For Less

Mary Kincaid: Weekly Roundup of eBay Vintage Home Finds (PHOTOS)

Carine Roitfeld, Janet Jackson, Karl Lagerfeld, and More at Last Night’s amfAR Gala in Cannes

Natalia Vodianova Was Royal in Blue

Cathy Horyn Deems Mickey Drexler’s Life ‘Not the Stuff of Novels’

Scrub Down: Hadali Detoxifying Body Scrub

Dressed In White: Sophie Theallet Sea Island White Cotton Gown

Patriotic Purse: Edie Parker Red, White and Blue Jean Clutch

Heat It Up: 5 Cool Outfits Inspired by Our Favorite Summer Movies

One Awesome Thing: A Swimsuit to Make You Feel Like a Bond Girl

Look of the Day: Leopard Meets Brights

Kim Kardashian a Kopy Kat?

Priscilla Chan’s Wedding Secret

Mozart Meets the Future

EVEN MORE ON Stylelist

Design
Clean Home
Beauty
Home Design
 
  • Terms of Service
  • Privacy Policy
  • Trademarks
  • Advertise
  • About Our Ads
  • Get AOL
 
 
© 2012 AOL Inc. All Rights Reserved