Given that women come in different shapes and sizes, it can be hard to find the perfect pair of boots for our legshape. And now that it's fall, the time to select that all important footwear that is both fancy and functional is upon us.

Over the knee boots have gained momentum, but while outré styles are perfect for the runway, how do they translate for real women with shorter or wider legs?

For our this week's testing the garment segment, we decided to send our merry band of fashion reviewers to Payless to find out if the Madge Flat Over the Knee Boots are universally alluring or better sitting pretty on the shelf.

As per the custom, the savvy shoppers (some of whom are bloggers, while others are not) headed to their local shopping mall to try on these reasonably priced ($59.99) kickers. The overall consensus? Whether pulled over opaque tights or worn with skinny jeans these saucy shoes proved to be a bit of a challenge for our reviewers.

But don't take our word for it. Find out what these women, who are of varying style and body types, had to say about size, fit, and fabrication as it pertains to these super boots.

Make sure to enlarge the gallery to full-screen -- and let us know if you're a fan of the style of these boots by leaving a comment.

For simple fall pieces to wear with your super stylish shoes, check out how to wear the minimalist trend.